WILLISTON (AP) - A Williston doctor has been cleared in a civil defamation lawsuit filed by another doctor who assisted him in a kidney removal operation four years ago.

A jury cleared Salem Shahin of the allegations by Inder Khokha.

The patient involved in the 2004 operation later died. Her son filed a wrongful death lawsuit against the two doctors. Shahin settled out of court, but the lawsuit continued against Khokha.

Khokha alleged in his civil defamation lawsuit that Shahin gave family members of the patient who died inaccurate information about his work during the operation. The jury disagreed.