Bismarck Tribune - North Dakota News - Indian Heritage Month ignored

Indian Heritage Month ignored

Nov 15, 2008 - 04:06:07 CST

As north winds whip across the prairies and mountains, we should expect to hear more conversational gusts about Native people as we reach the midway peak of American Indian Heritage Month.

Or will we?

It reminds me of the International Decade of the World's Indigenous People that ended in 2004, a 10-year timeframe to recognize the rights of the world's 370 million indigenous people.

Few people knew the decade existed.

In order to give it the attention it deserved, the U.N. Permanent Forum on Indigenous Peoples adopted a second decade for indigenous peoples in 2005.

Before the second decade ended, forum members set a goal of having the U.N. General Assembly adopt the Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.

For more than 25 years, indigenous peoples lobbied for the declaration. In September 2007, 143 member nations of the General Assembly finally adopted it. While the day marked a significant victory for indigenous groups worldwide, four countries voted against the declaration, including the United States.

As we reach mid-November, it's not a big surprise that American Indian Heritage Month seems to have as much relevance on the national public agenda as a fly has to a herd of buffalo.

The inattention is not for lack of importance, given that Native people are the only group in the United States with a unique political relationship with the federal government based on legally binding treaty agreements.

"It was wrong to not support the declaration; we urge them to reconsider and sign off on it," John Garcia, president of the National Congress of American Indians, said on Wednesday. "We're talking about the rights of peoples, not so much indigenous peoples but the rights of people. If they don't believe that in their heart, then what are they to believe? And what is the general population of America to believe?"

The NCAI is the largest organization of tribal governments in the United States. And Garcia poses a good question.

Without the United States' support for the declaration, it's easier for the American public to diminish the collective rights of American Indian peoples, who have the right to retain language, land and culture, and pursue education and live healthy lives imbued with a strong tribal identity.

Our Native youth particularly deserve recognition in a country that typically chooses to ignore them. Who are they if no one knows they exist?

American Indian Heritage Month appears to be slipping away with little national, regional or local fanfare.

"It's like America doesn't want to have a memory," said Julie Cajune, a Salish educator from the Flathead Reservation. "America chooses to have amnesia. What happens when a country chooses to not remember? It's a denial of identity."

Cajune's comments were used in a Native American Heritage Day video made for the state of Montana's Indian Education Office Web site. It can be viewed at www.opi.mt.gov/streamer/IHD.

"There needs to be a broadening of public knowledge," Garcia said. "We haven't taken advantage of the fact that we can do a lot more, rather than just leave it to chance. As the nation is moving in a new direction with the new administration, it's prime time we step up to the plate."

While Native perspectives have historically suffered in the daily discourse, we can easily take advantage of platforms that allow us to do it more easily, such as November's American Indian Heritage Month.

(Reach reporter Jodi Rave at jodi.rave@lee.net or 800-366-7186.)

News > State

Printer friendly version Indian Heritage Month ignored

Comments

marie wrote on Nov 30, 2008 11:23 PM:

" Ibelieve it is not relly powerful or wise to contribute to these blogs. They the comments are mainly ignored and the writers are bothered by the quality of the replys. There must be a better way of getting a power base in govenment. The door watchers just shut them when anyone talks about how ripped off the Native Americans are and how it is still happening.What newspaper for all tribes,what radio station for all tribes. What legitimate law enforcement for all tribes? As humans all tribes have rights.I belive we the Native Americans need to go through everything taught by our leades and throw out the garbage.Even if they have clout or money.The gossip and intimidation shown to the few who speak out need not be happening. Surely we are a better people then that. A poet "

Just the way it is.... wrote on Nov 27, 2008 6:20 PM:

" But of course Indian Heritage Month is being ignored by the people..... generally speaking, populations follow leaders, and there isn't a civic leader in Bismarck - Mandan that gives two wipes about the Indian people.

There are no Native Americans sitting on any of the city boards, or county commissioners.

The Native sculptures down along the river regularly get vandalized, with no public response from any city leader.

Our children know more derogative words for Native Americans than they do for African Americans or people of any other minority.

It made national news when a local guy was encouraged by Mandan's city leaders to buy a nice chunk of Crying Hill so he could turn around and donate it back to the city. THEN the city turned him down under pressure from a few area white supremists and together they took turns throwing egg on his face.

There are no Native American holidays, either locally, regionally or nationally, yet it was the Native Americans who REALLY founded this country. We "other ones" just invaded it later on.

No one can be surprised that we as a people don't celebrate Native American Heritage Month. After all, we are only celebrating that which our leaders create activities for, and lead us into to. "

Kimberly wrote on Nov 26, 2008 10:11 AM:

" As far as I see it, if we can have a Black History Month, we should freely and willingly recognize an Indian Heritage Month. Natives have a beautiful culture that should be preserved instead wiped away like some have been trying to do for centuries. What on Earth is so wrong with that, and why are people on here so against it? Maybe, as a German from Russia who is very in touch with her ancestory, I can somewhat relate (not the full extent of course) to what it is like to have your people exiled, discriminated, and be forced into an altogether different culture/religion. The difference is, though, that today I am a white American who does not experience racism. Natives don't have that luxury. I actually grew up next to Sioux county and made to believe that they were bad in some way and to fear them. Thankfully I have risen above that stereotype. If only more people could embrace our differences and learn from each other, maybe things could get a little better around here. If we want to be respected, shouldn't we respect others? "

IDK wrote on Nov 25, 2008 11:46 PM:

" I guess don't understand this, why is there even a place to comment about the original piece? I would guess it would be to disagree about what the writer stated, right? But I haven't read 1 comment that gave an example to even contradict the name of the story. It just seems that there are a lot of people upset that subject was brought up. Minneapolis, MN is roughly 6-8 hours from Bismarck, ND, it has a developed Native American community, and voice (I mean the star tribune has Native writers and editors bistrib, come on already). BUT these Native men and women, had to stand up 30 or 40 years ago, create non profits to empower themselves, create learning/community/workforce centers, and from that came positive Native American leaders who enrich the entire community. Leaders that will work with tribal/technical leaders to better the entire community. That is what needs to happen here. Help empower these people so that they can empower themselves, so they don't feel like Indian Heritage Month is ignored. "

soiamaree wrote on Nov 25, 2008 9:10 PM:

" pologist i agree with you in many fashions. Throughout the history of earth, within each race, nation, culture, people...there have been wars, assimilation, annihilation, growth, harmony, and little unity here and there. If history books are correct about how man was nomadic from his early beginnings, i dont believe that there is one true race. We are born covered in our mother's blood and we turn to dust. I do not merely teach my children about native americans and what was happening to them in the early years of our country...i try to teach about all nations i can find on this earth. I do that so they understand that different is not less, not worse...it is the beauty of god. Compassion is vital with an open mind to experience "different." The things that have happened in this country to the poor, uneducated, powerless happen all over the planet all at the hands of one person's "grand idea." Those people who have committed these acts are dead so hate should die too. Native American Heritage month is a calendar theme....a theme. I wonder if anyone made the connection that native american day is in september and native american heritage month is november? For all my beautiful human beings who dwell on this big rock, please let the anger go. It comes from pain you experienced in your life that you hold onto. For every act i count about something a white has done against a native/person of color there is an equally horrible act that was done to them by a person of color or a native. All of this talk about rights and what belongs to who is humorous as none of us are promised to live through the night..... "

Pologist wrote on Nov 25, 2008 4:41 PM:

" It was the duty of the early Christians of Spain, England, Portugal, and even Russia to erase the heathen paganism practiced here and replace it with the only true religion. Spain did the best job of any.
The Russians in Alaska did the best job of total cultural destruction.
But it is interesting to see pictures of old Churches in Mexico (was New Spain) where more than half the symbols represent the previous religion. The language spoken is about half the language of Spain. But then again the language of Spain is only about half the language of the Romans who ruled them before the Moors.
Why do we use the word Latin America if the language is less than one fourth Latin? Perhaps because it was a major victory for the Pope? And many of the early Europeans in New England had been fleeing the 30 years war with the Catholics. (See 30 Years War) "

Pologist wrote on Nov 25, 2008 4:15 PM:

" Native Americans were easy because they were always fighting among each other for hunting areas and stealing women.
The landmass of Europe was utilized more effectively by raising more modern crops and animals. When the Kings of Spain, Portugal, England, France, Russia and Holland got wind of this underutilized country they quickly sent either armies or colonists to every natural seaport. So Europeans did exactly what many or most of the Native Americans had done. With a much higher birth rate from modern agriculture and European diseases the end should have been obvious from the start.
First to arrive was the Italian (Columbus) who had sailed for Portugal and had learned how to use the navigational tools used by the Moors. The Crusader Knights that had pushed the Moors back across the Mediteranean had made all this possible.
So Spain took over most Islands, Mexico and Central America.
Portugal took over the east coast of South America.
Russia took Alaska fighting coastal Natives down to the Russian town above San Francisco.
Spain knew of Russias movements and occupied the southern coast of California up to the great harbor of San Francisco. (Harbors were very precious back then).
As England and France argued about the Hudson Bay, eventually a French Colony moved to New Orleans eventually claiming the land we later referred to as the Louisiana Purchase (center third of US?).
Basically the same thing happened here that happened all over Europe and everyone mostly erased or combined the previous culture.
A TV program on an archeological dig at biblical Jericho claimed that excavations showed 40 layers of civilizations that we know almost nothing about. Was it mostly war or plague, of combinations of both like in this country?
The next major World War will probably be Nuclear or Biological and like Islam and Christian Mid East any victors will not care about previous history.
Maybe if we put time capsules of each of our histories on the Moon and Mars before it is to late. "

Notnek wrote on Nov 25, 2008 9:14 AM:

" Ijfrommin: Yes many immigrants suffered at the hands of their countrymen. Many immigrants, probably most ,came here for free land. None of that really matters now, as sooner or later a more dominate culture was going to inhabit North America. The point here is nothing more, than recognition, of Indians that were removed from the land as the mass migration to America took over. I would love to hear your side of Spirit Lake Man. The general public is totally unaware of the reasons to reclaim ancestral remains.. Later "

SV wrote on Nov 25, 2008 12:28 AM:

" Thanks Giving??? What thanks!! and what giving??? "

Dangit why cant we all get along wrote on Nov 24, 2008 11:40 PM:

" why can't we comment along!!! :-) DON'T HATE...APPRICIATE!!! were all Human Beings "

ljfrommin wrote on Nov 24, 2008 9:13 PM:

" In a different vein--

Why where the mummified remains of Spirit Cave Man destroyed? C'mon, you know why. That mummy's DNA proved that there were caucasians in North America from the pre Stone Age era. But before scientist could verify that fact the remains were claimed under "aboriginal law" and "ceremoniously" disposed of. Hence preserving "indigenous rights". On that note, I will gladly go toe to toe with any native on pre-Colombian American history! "

ljfrommin wrote on Nov 24, 2008 4:20 PM:

" The German speaking Russians that are in North Dakora today were a people driven from their land also. They were scattered throughout the world but established large enclaves in North Dakota, Texas and Argentina. Those that remained were killed. There is not one village remaining in Russia that still bears it's Germanic name. Now THAT's ethnic cleansing. "

Notnek wrote on Nov 24, 2008 3:59 PM:

" Please,,,,, Teaching,------ history from 50s B westerns is hardly reality.. Counting coup meant touching. Scalping,, was introduced as a means of collecting bountys. Pologist, The houses you refer to, were rectangles, life of my ancestors was governed by a circle. A great spiritual leader observed even the birds built there nests in a circle. His name was Black Elk . The book Black Elk Speaks is a wonderful source for understanding more about Indian spirituality. "

SR_Warrior Fan wrote on Nov 24, 2008 2:46 PM:

" Its funny how we come to these debates.......LOL....I was reading some of the comments and concerns that people around the state have with a Heritage Month and come to the conclusion most people have nothing better to do with there day. I myself am a Native American and love every aspect of it.......I teach my children that they were truely blessed to be born of Native American descent and also to respect all people, NO MATTER WHAT BACKGROUND!!!!!!!!!........I remember my grandpa told stories of things that he endured in his life (some real happy and others real sad)........He talked of being forced away from his home, because the area was to be flooded by dams and taken away from his family and sent to boarding schools. He also talked of war and of friends he lost in battles (White, Black and Brown).......He was truely an exceptional man.......I truely wish one day we can all have a day, week or month to show the good that all people contributed to this great nation.......It is true that we were the first people to live on this big island, but now we share it with relatives and we all need to get along........"Its a great time we have our first black president People".........Remember love not hate. "

Pologist wrote on Nov 24, 2008 2:38 PM:

" To soIamaree
Various so-called minorities in this country are militarizing their youth. They only tell one side of history.
Whenever a story is told or printed that only tells one side I find it very sad.
Unfortunate that our European History is taught with so much bias as to be very boring. So many people in this country have been brainwashed into believing they are part of Columbus or the Old Testament it is amazing. DNA would tell a different story.
So unless the schools are permitted to teach real history of all cultures we should stop all these cultural celebrations. One sided victim history is very polarizing.
It was not only this country where hundreds of thousands of people died of diseases from exposure to another people. It was not only this country where people were forced to learn a new language or religion.
It is actually a very normal part of the human experience. Slavery is one of the most common parts of the human experience and was practiced in every country. That includes this country prior to European migration.
As a very educated Me-Wuk friend once told me in jest you white people are descended from monkeys, we are descended from Bears.
Jest is often good, combined with honesty about everyone it works even better.
And the many Europeans captured by Indians were treated very badly. Just like in all wars everywhere.
The Indian Boarding Schools were an attempt to do things better than were being done previously. If you yourself were not spanked in public school, and do not know anyone spanked in Catholic school, you are comparatively young. Now big city children run in gangs to see who can control the school grounds.
Now schools give mind numbing medications to so called hyperactive children who cannot sit still all day.
I was once told that when Indians were first given houses they would put their animals in the houses and live outside in the traditional way? "

teaching wrote on Nov 24, 2008 2:27 PM:

" I love how it's stated everyone was at peace until the calvary came. That indians only "counted coup" and never desired, attempted, or accomplished the total destruction of other people and tribes all by themselves. That is the popular history. No one likes to talk how entire tribes were wiped out by their "loving" indian neighbors. To truly read the history, one cannot ignore the nastiness that existed for thousands of years, long before the "white man" arrived. It's a human condition to be that way, not related to skin color in the least. I find it hypocritical in it's utmost. "

Enough Already wrote on Nov 24, 2008 8:20 AM:

" I like to attend events at the local colleges for Native American Month. I take my kids with me to learn and see. I don't feel as though it's heavily commercialized. Nor is it the only month that I, myself and my children and friends learn about the past, present and future of native americans. Just this month in the local high school a friend's daughter is giving a presentation is on Boarding Schools. She is interested in the topic because it's not something you learn about in school and she heard us talking about it. To soIamaree: Great job. "

Pologist wrote on Nov 23, 2008 10:50 PM:

" A good picture is worth a thousand words.
http://www.nga.gov/exhibitions/brushinfo.shtm
For over 100,000 years all of our ancestors lived much like this. Dream of the freedom expressed in this painting.
Forget for a moment the kingdoms of Rome and Egypt of the last 2 or 3 thousand years. That is brief recent history. Most of our history we were free and not owned by any king. Most of our ancestors were free. The heyday of our cousins the apes was 20,000,000 (yes million) years ago.
The above picture was found at
http://www.loc.gov/topics/nativeamericans/ "

Pologist wrote on Nov 23, 2008 1:23 PM:

" We really do need to encourage more native celebrations. We need more studies of their cultural history. If necessary federal money needs to be spent to help.
This continent was kept separate from the great kingdoms of Europe by the oceans for thousands of years. It was a time capsule into the past. How else will we get a clear picture of how our own stone age ancestors survived without kings.
We have selfishly dug up Native bones and put them in museums and studied their stone tool kits.
These children of the forests and plains who belonged to no Noble, and paid taxes to no King. They had their societies of the ten bravest who would rush to confront all dangers voluntarily. The women could gather from the forests and make a home.
We have not finished putting their culture under the microscope. Our television shows always portray our own stone-age man as awkward and uncoordinated. Before cameras the early painters showed a much different picture with the Native Americans.
Those who wish to preserve their Native history should have all possible help provided. To know them is to know our own ancestors a little better, and appreciate the hardships and victories. Such a shame the kings of Europe started New England, New Spain, and the various French and Dutch settlements in such a way as to exploit and cover over most local history and customs.
We already have a clear picture of what the cities of Europe were like. Most unfortunate that the concepts of this countries original peoples have always been interpreted through European Eyes.
If people were honest they would admit that numerically very few Europeans of the middle ages were rich and living in the Castle. Most of our ancestors were peasants planting and harvesting the Nobles crops so he could live in luxury. And most of our ancestors were driven out of Europe by wars and plagues. For most of our ancestors moving to this country and having ones own farm was a big step up. "

Mike R wrote on Nov 22, 2008 3:14 PM:

" a little different: Why is it that someone always claims that the 4th of July or columbus day, Thanksgiving, or (insert any national holiday here) is strictly a "Whitey" holiday? So I assume that minorities don't celebrate these days? They work while all us whitey are goofing off on our holidays? Just because it isn't a black or native american holiday does not IN ANY WAY make it a "Whitey" holiday. A holiday is a holiday is a holiday without regard to race in any way unless race is specifically inserted into it. Us "Whitey" folks have integrated and become one people and celebrate common holidays. Some minority groups insist on having thier own holidays, thier own history, etc. They are the ones trying to seperate themselves from society, then they complain that they are not treated as equal. To be equal, one has to accept equality. Different but equal has never worked, but we are not the ones handing out that label. They are the ones demanding it. "

a little different wrote on Nov 22, 2008 12:04 PM:

" to fuzzhezy - A national Whitey day? What is Columbus Day? What is the fourth of July? What is Presidents day (up until now) ? What is Thanksgiving? I think ALL these have been a tribute to, as you call yourself, the "Whiteys".

I'm not saying I agree or disagree with National Native American Heritage month - I'm not saying I think that should be more of a celebration or more recognized. It's just saying you are ignorant. "

ndokie wrote on Nov 22, 2008 9:06 AM:

" Maybe the Native American communities just want what was forcibly taken away from them.
As for "whitey"--we've always had our day, month, year, festivals, and usually at the expense of other races.
Solamaree, you are a wise and inspirational woman. Thank you for teaching truth to your children, and for instilling in them the best of your culture.
What I am reading in these comments is a great deal of ignorance, fear, and greed. Now I remember why I left North Dakota more than 30 years ago. And as much as I love the geography of the place, I can't imagine subjecting my soul to its social climate. "

Notnek wrote on Nov 22, 2008 9:05 AM:

" Solamaree, A very nice and factual response to this discussion. I have always found it hard to understand the misconception of why, how our (Indian) culture is regarded by a few with such disdain. Very little consideration is given to the great changes that have taken place since the 1960s. The majority of the negative remarks have none, or are unwilling to put any understanding and history into focus, of how our culture has reacted to circumstances totally beyond our control. We are sovereign, yet we also take part in the U S economy. We also must return to out roots- building our community one person at a time. "

Mike R wrote on Nov 22, 2008 8:00 AM:

" To "I remember Mike R" Go back and read the comment posted by Halabis on Nov 21. That pretty much says it all right there. You can tell me how racist I am all you want, but the true definition of a racist comes from someone's actions. The actions of native americans make it clear that they want to be a seperate group. You can call me the racist if you want to, but I see it differently. By the way, which leader would you suggest head up the celebration? You say it shouldn't be up to the tribal leaders or the tech school, so who then? It is a native american celebration. I say it should be up to the native americans to pick a leader to promote this. Why wouldn't it be up to them to promote thier own celebration? Really, I want to know. "

fuzzhezy wrote on Nov 22, 2008 12:33 AM:

" I am so sick of this only the WHITE MAN is racist. You are crazy if you think that. What would happen if we had a National Whitey Day? What would happen if we had a Miss White Pageant? What would happen if we gave scholarships only to whites? Let's give them there holiday and give us one too and see what happens, Wait, that is racism. Why should whites get a holiday for themselves. The African Americans have one, the indians want one, why cant we? The only thing that makes labeling, is the people that bring it on themselves. So if you dont want a white trailer trash label or something else, straighten out. "

I remember Mike R wrote on Nov 21, 2008 8:29 PM:

" Oh Mike R, always trying to get the subject back to UND like a good PR professional... The fact is that their is no celebration of Native American anything, be day, week, month, or hour. The state capital has a huge population of Native American but 1. does not have any Native Leaders to make this month stand out from every other month (and no it does not fall squarely on the shoulders on a Technical college president and 1 Tribal leader no matter how you smear them, and 2. the Caucasian community in the state of North Dakota are incredibly racist and oppressive. I mean honestly, how many native non profits exists in the state? Programs that are designed to enrich an develop a community that has been oppressed for over 500 hundred years? How many Native Americans work for the Bismarck Tribune in an editorial or columnist position? Seriously. The Native Americans in North Dakota are oppressed. The tribes that have been given a say about the UND have voted to remove the name Mike R. Why would the Tribes trust
anything the school does until the name is removed? "

soIamaree wrote on Nov 21, 2008 8:18 PM:

" given that it is native american month or heritage month, i have one question in my mind that goes unanswered. I am from fort berthold so yes i am an arikara but during this month, i do not look forward to seeing or hearing about native americans in an academic or commercialized fashion. It just doesnt happen. BUT what i do during this month is teach my children about the history of the indigenous people in this country. I teach them about boarding schools, sterilization policies, and other things that the elders do not speak about. I hear the argument about getting recognized but...and im gonna get slammed for this...there are not many who will share or speak about what they went through specifically. Every other race i see in this nation tells the story of what was done wrong to them, slavery, for example, is widely spoken of all througout the US. Where are the stories? Where are grandmas troubles? What actually happened? What were the names of the people involved in our history? There is a responsibility that parents have to educate their children. Parent is defined as to teach...is this not the perfect month to sit down with a grandpa or grandma or mother or father to talk about the things that happened to them. I am 30 years old and it wasnt until recently when i "youtubed" the word 'boarding schools' and found out what happened to native children that went. And both my parents went to wahpeton in the 50s! This is the month to teach brothers, sisters, fellow humans....and it should start in the home. This is the month to find out something new. Instead of all this useless arguing about the the american tradition of racism why not focus more on our families and look together for something new to learn about native americans. I suppose that would be to much to ask people to do. "

Halabis wrote on Nov 21, 2008 6:33 PM:

" In the 1950's the U.S.Supreme Court ruled that separate but equal was not equal--that started the integration of all parts of American public facilities including education, housing, etc. You may take this any way you wish---When a population chooses to set itself apart, the message to others is that they do not want to mix with those around them. It matters not what you say you deserve, or that you were here first, or that the majority is biased---the fact remains that we do not know you as we know our neighbors because you are not neighbors. You have set youselves apart. I have no way to get to know you. Nor do you have a way to get to know me. We are both the poorer for it. "

Mike R wrote on Nov 21, 2008 5:16 PM:

" UND tried to celebrate Indian Heritage, but then the Indian leaders called it hate speech and filed a lawsuit, so we started to forget about it because obviously they didn't like it. Now we are condemned because we are forgetting about it. It is all so very confusing. "

to ENOUGH wrote on Nov 21, 2008 3:46 PM:

" your quote "What makes people think that all native americans are the same as you perceive them to be? " is dead on. Here's the problem; as a rule caucasians do not have self proclaimed 'ethnic' leaders. This "one size fits all" form of tribal politics is very polarizing. "

Enough Already wrote on Nov 21, 2008 1:59 PM:

" Most of the negative comments about american indians/natives are pretty much based on assumptions with maybe a small percentage on reality. What makes people think we are proud only one month out of the year? What makes people think that all native americans are the same as you perceive them to be? "

X-nodac wrote on Nov 21, 2008 1:15 PM:

" As an ex north dakotian I enjoy this web site. One thing I've noticed is the fact that any artical about Native Americans generate the most negitive responces. As a white man growing up there it was a great place to live. But being married to a Navajo, ( 20 year retired veteren) it sure changes my view of the state. Last year after reading about lack of workers in the state, our 22 year old, university educated clean cut,son went up to check it out. His experence was terrible! Businessmen doing the hiring need to look beyond the skin tone. He was hired by a international corp. in Williston & doing fine.It's the locals who look first and are rude. "

str8 up wrote on Nov 21, 2008 1:13 PM:

" This article is making people aware that there is an "American Indian Heritage Month," and that it might be fading away. It isn't as though the individuals mentioned in the article are forcing a it upon everyone. It is just hoping to create an awareness. There a few posts on this article made by people that seem to feel that Native Americans aren't worth the time of day...let alone a WHOLE
MONTH?

"There needs to be a broadening of public knowledge," Garcia said.

This seems to be key...because there is a strong negative correlation between racism and education. So, ideally the more people know about Native Americans the less likely they are to hold racist views. However, when you are dealing with people that are brought up with racist views that go back generations and are deeply instilled like some of the posters on this website...who wants to waste time and energy? let them gripe about issues unrelated to the topic at hand (Swedish culture and contributions, or Italian, or Albanian, boycotting all things owned or operated by the tribes, The Mexican peoples started Cinco De Mayo, I did have some buffalo jerky the other day) "

arlo wrote on Nov 21, 2008 12:02 PM:

" If you linve in America and are legal you are an American. If the Reservations want to celebrate great. Why should America? We would be celebrating a different culture everyday if we did it for every ethnic group and some would have to share days, then war would break out. Although I did have some buffalo jerky the other day does that count has celebrating? "

hugo wrote on Nov 21, 2008 11:49 AM:

" the article being posted since early november is evidence of tribunes efforts on keeping racism alive in bismarck north dakota. "

idea wrote on Nov 21, 2008 10:44 AM:

" I Got It!! Why don't we start an American Heritage Lifetime so that all americans can celebrate their heritage all the time. Isn't that fair? That way you can be proud of who you are and where you came from all of the time, as it should be. "

Not so different wrote on Nov 21, 2008 8:53 AM:

" Sorry, but the Native Americans are not so DIFFERENT from everyone else, and I think it is time someone realized this. How is it that your relatives are Mexican but didn't come from Mexico? Because California (along with Texas, New Mexico and Arizona) was conquered in the name of the US, and the citizens of those areas became citizens of the US while maintaining their ethnic identities. Imagine that, ethnic groups maintaining their ethnic pride and identities without special privileges, lands or national identities. So many people know of Cinco de Mayo, but who ever heard of Hispanic Heritage Month? Hispanics know who they are and they live it, speak it, celebrate it - they don't wait around for someone else to "recognize" it. Yet, in the process they have gained the recognition of the nation which increasing joins in celebrating the Independence Day of our Mexican brothers and sisters. It just proves the old adage once again: laugh and the world laughs with you, complain and - well you get the picture. Be a proud people and you will gain the respect and pride of others, demand respect and, well, you'll just get resentment. "

ndokie wrote on Nov 21, 2008 8:35 AM:

" I am appalled at most of the comments made thus far.
The word "assimilation" has been frequently used, not only toward indigenous peoples, but toward all people who strike us as "different." Seems a number of you want to strip others of their unique racial and cultural identities and turn them into something that is just like you. Don't tell me you still believe in the melting pot myth--the melting pot that never was.

White men may not be raiding the encampments and villages of our indigenous tribes anymore, but by deny them their rightful place, not honoring their rights, and not supporting them in the recovery and perpetuation of their rich tribal cultures--and actually working in opposition to these endeavors--we continue the oppression begun the day the first white man set foot on this continent.

Growing up near Ft. Berthold, my parents took me to Mandaree for the dances and celebrations; they saw to that I learned about the Mandan-Arikara-Hidatsa peoples firsthand. It was important to them that I respect and appreciate the richness of their culture and the wisdom of the elders. Living in Hawaii, I learned of indigenous Hawaiian culture from my Hawaiian neighbors. Now, living in the heart of Oklahoma, I live in the midst of tribal culture, and for that I am most grateful.

I have watched as over the decades, my indigenous neighbors have striven to overcome the social ills that for so long overshadowed their successes. Today, these tribes are vibrant, healthy, and a major contributor to the health and wellbeing of our community. Their business holdings are diverse, ranging from small industries to banks. And they continue to promote their traditional ways as ways of healing and wholeness for their people. It is so nice to see young people who are now proud of who and what they are. "

A little different wrote on Nov 20, 2008 11:48 AM:

" TO: to A little Differant - Again, that is why Native Americans are DIFFERENT from everyone else. Assimilation is a bad word when it pertains to Native Americans. Myself and many other Native Americans are very happy to be American, but do not necesarily want to be "assimilated". I think the beauty of American is all the different cultures and "flavors" of people. I think it would be sad for everyone to assimilate and be just like the next person.

I am also half hispanic. I come from a LARGE Mexican family from California. I do not know of any relatives that came from Mexico - all were born on American soil. But I know that my Mexican side does not struggle with their cultural or ethnic identies AT ALL. They know exactly where they originated from and what our culture and identity are.

As a Native American - *not speaking for anyone else* - that identity and/or culture is a little less clear at times. - that's what I mean by Native Americans are a little different than the average Nationality group. "

OMG wrote on Nov 20, 2008 10:49 AM:

" The Mexican peoples started Cinco de Mayo? How about they brought the tradition of celebrating Cinco de Mayo from thier home country? Wow. Not even close to the same type of thing. Cinco de Mayo is not a month set aside for the country to celebrate thier heritage. It is just a holiday that they celebrate as Hispanics and everyone else is invited to join. There is however a Hispanic Heritage Month that starts in September. While I had to laugh along with comments like 'fuzzhezy', What is the big deal, as someone else posted, who is stopping you from celebrating German Heritage Month or whatever heritage you are? Try Googling it. It exsists, we just don't make a big deal of it around here because apparently we don't have as much pride as the Natives do in our heritage. "

indigenous gal wrote on Nov 19, 2008 10:48 PM:

" So WHAT is holding anyone back from making a National Indigenous Heritage Day / Week / Month?
Rather than complain, get up - go forth - make-it-happen!!!!!
The Mexican peoples started Cinco De Mayo (do you think they waited for the white people to create this holiday for them? I don't think so. Quit complaining - be proactive. "

fuzzhezy wrote on Nov 19, 2008 5:36 PM:

" WOW!
Thanks for all that you do in our society people. Without you, our lives would not go on. You show us how to go out and put extra effort into getting jobs. You show us how to keep up our homes. You show us how to celebrate ones accomplishments. Thanks for all that you do! "

You know wrote on Nov 19, 2008 4:52 PM:

" We tried to honor the native people of this region at the University of North Dakota and we all know how that is working out. I would hate to offend the likes for David Gipp or Ron and His Mule Thunder by celebrating the earlier immigrants to this region. Remember, you reap what you sow. I for one have continued boycotting all things owned or operated by the tribes in ND and I will continue to do so until such time as the "Fighting Sioux" logo issue is resolved to my satisfaction.

Until then, have a nice day. "

to A little Differant wrote on Nov 19, 2008 11:06 AM:

" The Swedes, Italians and Albanians you speak of are DESCENDANTS and truly consider this to be THEIR country. These people may be proud of their heritage but are eager to assimilate. i know of no one in ND that reads, writes or does business in Swedish, Italian or Albanian. They all seem quite content to use the foreign tongue, English. There can be no real advancement on this issue, because those that set themselves apart, will be apart. That is a universal truth! "

so wrote on Nov 19, 2008 10:41 AM:

" Whatever, the weak didnt prevail so there for who cares!!! "

Sk wrote on Nov 19, 2008 8:11 AM:

" Ha thats funny if you think Obama will help Native Americans, because he wont. There is no financial or political gain to do so. He will be busy enough spending the next 4 years trying to help more populous minorities, while not upsetting the majority. "

free will wrote on Nov 19, 2008 6:05 AM:

" Causes such as this need a better PR person. It is not that the general population wouldn't be willing to do something in regard to the month but what are Native Americans doing to celebrate? Is there a web site of activities and information? "

a reader wrote on Nov 18, 2008 1:38 AM:

" the united states government dispersed alot of trauma to all natives in building the new world. of course one does not want to look in their own backyard when trying to declare "native american month". that is why there has been little exposure. but i see alot of outcome in the native since this historic election. "

White Dove wrote on Nov 17, 2008 1:48 PM:

" Did you hear of Norsk Hostfest?
What a wonderful time to be alive
and know that commercialism is
the driving force in North Dakota? "

krten wrote on Nov 17, 2008 9:12 AM:

" Someone has to be a voice for the oppressed/marginalized, and it is great that the Tribune took the opportunity to bring attention to forefront with this article. Thanks! "

Think wrote on Nov 16, 2008 10:02 PM:

" These comments are the reason their is a month for the First Americans. Not for legal action, but for everyone to recognize these great people. Look at how many people comment negatively. There is no Native American voice in North Dakota, because so many are quick to oppress their voice. It's assimilation in the 21st century. "

Niyawehnsie wrote on Nov 16, 2008 10:24 AM:

" Heritage Month should clarify history and the contributions of Native Americans to our country, the first of which is the very foundation upon which this country is based, Freedom and Democracy, the representation of the People. This country's constitution is a poorly plagerised version of the Haudenosaunee Constitution given to them by Creators Messenger, the Peacemaker... not as is taught God-given to a bunch from 1700 patriarchal supremacy of the rich white males. It took this country 150 years to catch up to the rights the Native Women had since the beginning of time. Its time to tell the truth and give Native Americans the proper place in history and the respect this US has not ever given. The Woodland peoples of our First Nations, had a True Democracy, The First United Nations comprised of at least 70 nations, and they had a society with no poor, no orphans, and no jails... tell me what in the Present Day equals those accomplishements... just maybe there is something to be learned from the First Nations Peoples...... "

A little different - To Heritage Month wrote on Nov 15, 2008 4:23 PM:

" Native Americans are a little different than Swedens, Italians, and Albanians. The difference? Those three HAVE their OWN country. Native Americans once did, but no longer do. "

Dumb Cracker wrote on Nov 15, 2008 11:19 AM:

" For American Indians, something should be done about broken treaties. I don't think an effort like this heritage month is going to cut it. "

Edward wrote on Nov 15, 2008 11:02 AM:

" I am confuded. Who is it that will not allow native americans the "right to retain language, land and culture, and pursue education and live healthy lives imbued with a strong tribal identity." "

Halatbis wrote on Nov 15, 2008 8:39 AM:

" Perhaps you are looking for something that is not going to happen anymore than a National or worldwide month of recognition of Swedish culture and contributions, or Italian, or Albanian. "

heritage month wrote on Nov 15, 2008 6:57 AM:

" That's the whole problem I have with it. "Heritage month" has nothing to do with heritage; rather, it is a perversion of a great opportunity for history to be discussed. Instead, it is a just a glorified effort to shore up future legal action. If you believe you will change public opinion or that of Congress by suing people, there is no wonder what the reaction will be. In effect, this document would come first before the U.S. Constitution. I have as so many others do as well, have a problem with that.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Declaration_on_the_Rights_of_Indigenous_Peoples "

Post Your Own Comment

All online comments are limited to 350 words total.
Comments are reviewed for taste, tone and language before posting.
Some comments may be used in the Tribune's print edition.
We value and respect your privacy, but The Bismarck Tribune might
disclose certain information to governmental entities if served with subpoena.